* All State # All American ^Academic All American ~All Region
| Year | Name | Position |
| 2009 | Cunningham, Danny | Def |
| 2009 | Dwyer, Tabor | Mid |
| 2009 | Gambrell, Matt | Att |
| 2009 | Popwell, David~ | Mid |
| 2009 | Sandefer, Fred | Def |
| 2009 | Tanner, Matt | Mid |
| 2008 | Byrum, Zach* | Def |
| 2008 | Cassidy, Patrick* | Mid |
| 2008 | Curran, Patrick | Att |
| 2008 | Fitzhugh, Sean* | Mid |
| 2008 | Franklin, William*## | Att |
| 2008 | Hamlet, Trey | Def |
| 2008 | Hayes, Jordan | Goal |
| 2008 | Hebert, Jason | Mid |
| 2008 | Jennings, Joe* | Def |
| 2008 | Kennedy, Matt | Att |
| 2008 | Knotts, Arthur | Att |
| 2008 | Lifka, Welling | Def |
| 2008 | McCaskey, Tyler* | Def |
| 2008 | Quinn, Patrick* | Goal |
| 2008 | Sneed, Shay | Def |
| 2008 | Threlkeld, John | Def |
| 2008 | Vihlen, Nolan* | Mid |
| 2007 | Lanigan, David | Def |
| 2007 | Wimbish, Will | Def |
| 2007 | Pearce, Josh | Def |
| 2007 | O'Leary, Kelly* | Mid |
| 2007 | Chianella, Bryan* | Att |
| 2007 | Weaver, Preston* | LSM |
| 2007 | Schifani, Steve | Att |
| 2006 | Carter, Miles | Mid |
| 2006 | Croce, Matt | Def |
| 2006 | Darrohn, Spencer | Mid |
| 2006 | Dunn, Brook | Mid |
| 2006 | Haaga, Ed | Def |
| 2006 | Haaga, Matt | Def |
| 2006 | Heard, Tony* | Att |
| 2006 | Lanigan, Thomas | Def |
| 2006 | McArthur, John | Def |
| 2006 | McClelland, Drew*^ | Def |
| 2006 | Regenold, Nick | Def |
| 2006 | Samuels, Tyler* | Mid/Att |
| 2006 | Solon, Evan | Mid |
| 2006 | Stephens, Will | Mid |
| 2006 | Stringfellow, Alex | Mid |
| 2006 | Yatsula, Kyle | Mid |
| 2005 | Hackett, William* | Mid |
| 2005 | Hollis, Patrick | Mid |
| 2005 | Newsham, William | Mid |
| 2005 | Schaeffer, Phillip* | Def |
| 2005 | Stringfellow, Sam* | Def |
| 2005 | Taylor, Chris* | Goal |
| 2004 | Brady, Kyle | Def |
| 2004 | Cooke, Spencer* | Att |
| 2004 | Daley, Luke | Mid |
| 2004 | Franks, Michael | Def |
| 2004 | Gusmus, Michael | Mid |
| 2004 | Kelso, Doug | Def |
| 2004 | Kreager, Tony* | Def |
| 2004 | Lee, Jacob | Def |
| 2004 | Scarleski, Michael | Att |
| 2004 | Sneed, Tommy | Att |
| 2004 | Webb, Ryan | Mid |
| 2003 | Lester, Stephen* | Def |
| 2003 | Morrison, Michael | Mid |
| 2003 | Pontius, David* | Mid |
| 2003 | Robinson, Jay* | Def |
| 2003 | Smith, Drew | Att/Mid |
| 2003 | Wilkerson, Cory | Def |
| 2003 | Wills, Gordon | Mid |
| 2002 | Barry, Brendan | Mid |
| 2002 | Bazar, Adam | Def |
| 2002 | Beall, Kevin* | Mid |
| 2002 | Cappocia, Jonathan | Att |
| 2002 | Kirk, Burton | Att |
| 2002 | Miller, Thomas* | Mid |
| 2002 | Sanders, John | Att |
| 2001 | Fields, Brian | Mid |
| 2001 | Frey, Mike* | Mid |
| 2001 | Gwin, John | Def |
| 2001 | Morgan, Wes | Att |
| 2001 | Parthenais, Taylor* | Att |
| 2001 | Regenold, Seth | Mid |
| 2001 | Tuggle, Ty* | Def |
| 2000 | Hackett, Jason | Att |
| 2000 | Robinson, Ward | Mid |
| 2000 | Rossie, Newman* | Goal |
| 2000 | Slattery, Thomas* | Att |
| 1999 | Garibaldi, Matt | Mid |
| 1999 | Horner, Derek* | LSM |
| 1999 | Martin, Kevin | Mid |
| 1999 | Pzinski, Mark | Mid |
| 1999 | Shinnick, Conor* | Att |
| 1999 | Towery, Trey* | Goal |
| 1998 | Bazar, Matt* | Def |
| 1998 | Bladon, Patrick | |
| 1998 | Bosi, John Michael | |
| 1998 | Butterick, Ryan | Def |
| 1998 | Croxdale, Chris | |
| 1998 | Davis, Richard | |
| 1998 | Hudman, Michael* | Att |
| 1998 | Martini, Matt* | Att |
| 1998 | Morrison, Chris* | Att |
| 1998 | Ticer, Andy | |
| 1998 | Umstead, David | Def |
| 1997 | Brannon, George | |
| 1997 | Illagen, Jay | |
| 1997 | Kiser, Michael | |
| 1997 | Neale, Alex | Mid |
| 1997 | Nordberg, Tommy | Mid |
| 1997 | Ranson, Aaron | |
| 1997 | Rose, Robert | |
| 1997 | Salmon, Jeff | |
| 1997 | Walker, Sam | |
| 1997 | Ware, John | |
| 1996 | Bazar, Brian | |
| 1996 | Vetter, Paul | |
| 1995 | Buntin, Brad | |
| 1995 | Croxdale, Sean | Att |
| 1995 | Davis, Allen | |
| 1995 | Fernandez, Chip | |
| 1995 | Hackney, Joe | |
| 1995 | Haynes, Keith | |
| 1995 | Horner, Derek | Mid |
| 1995 | Hunt, Corbit | |
| 1995 | Lenihan, Michael | |
| 1995 | Martini, Nick* | Att |
| 1995 | McClellan, Ben | Att |
| 1995 | Miller, Thomas | |
| 1995 | Percoski, Zac | |
| 1995 | Shinnick, Brian# | Def |
| 1995 | Sparkman, Tim | |
| 1995 | Sturnavent, Rusty | |
| 1995 | Turner, Matt | |
| 1994 | Bush, Dave* | Mid |
| 1993 | Schaber, Kevin | Att |
| 1992 | Fuller, Patrick | Mid/Def |
| 1992 | Kimble, Ken | |
| 1992 | O'Connor, Larry | Att |
| 1992 | Wise, John | Mid |
| 1991 | Deitz, William | Mid |
| 1991 | Henderson, Brandon | Mid |
| 1991 | Hudson, Tom |